jackmyers.com
Free ContentFor Members Only
HOME MEDIAVILLAGE.com WOMEN ADVANCING HOOKED UP MEMBERSHIP INFO MEMBER COMPANIES MEDIA BUSINESS REPORT ECONOMIC FORECASTS RESEARCH
Home > MyersBizNet Media Business Report > TV Maven: YouTube Scientology Freeze: Coincidence or Censorship?

TV Maven: YouTube Scientology Freeze: Coincidence or Censorship?

February 14, 2008

Published: February 14, 2008 at 11:32 PM GMT
Last Updated: February 15, 2008 at 11:32 PM GMT

 
Suddenly the hottest topic on YouTube is Scientology. Some 5000 videos related to the church founded by L. Ron Hubbard have been uploaded to the video-sharing site over the past four weeks. Nearly 3000 of those have been added in the past week. Just today, Feb. 14, more than 250 new clips with “Scientology” in their tags have shown up.
 
But the content is not without controversy.
 
This guy claims that for 48 hours YouTube froze the view counts on videos criticizing Scientology, including hundreds of clips from last Sunday’s “Anonymous” protests at 250 church properties around the world.
 
My firsthand experience is that this did happen. I uploaded a 3:40 video of the Dallas protest around 4 p.m. Sunday. Within a few hours it had attracted hundreds of views and dozens of comments. But the count remained stuck on the number 761 from Sunday night to Tuesday afternoon, when it suddenly jumped to more than 3,000 views.
 
YouTube says this was a server problem: “There was an issue with video view counts not increasing that has now been resolved. The correct number of views should be displayed in the next 24 hours. Thanks for your patience.”
 
Conspiracy-lovers, such as the followers of Anonymous who took part in last Sunday’s anti-Scientology rallies, might say the coincidental freeze-ups helped keep all Scientology-related videos off YouTube’s front page. Certainly some of them would have qualified as “most-watched” on Sunday and Monday.
 
The original “Anonymous” message alone has garnered nearly 2.5 million views and has not yet been featured as a “most-watched.”
 
No similar glitches have been previously reported.
 
YouTube has been pressured by the Church of Scientology before to take down leaked footage of Tom Cruise in a church promo, and a three-hour speech by church leader David Miscavige.
 
Currently YouTube hosts more than 70 million videos and about 5 million user channels. 
 

Click Below to Follow the Coverage:
2/15/08 PM YouTube Yanks "Anonymous" Video
2/14/08 PM YouTube Scientology Freeze: Coincidence or Censorship?
2/14/08 AM Internet's "Anonymous" Puts Scientology and Tom Cruise on Notice

For more on this subject, check out Ed Martin's review of the South Park episode Trapped in the Closet and his column about the bizarre public behavior of Tom Cruise. Also read TVMaven's take on the infamous Tom Cruise Scientology video.

add this social bookmark link

2 Comments
Genny - February 15, 2008
Coincidence!? I don't think so... I guess that makes me a conspiracy lover?!! lol, Anyhow, I think it's just amazing what viral video can do, even to the biggest and richest organizations. Way to go Anonymous!
cheap soccer cleats - July 4, 2011

Fargo affiliate WDAY. It could be worse. So, I mean, mean, jordan shoes for sale mean, it's just one step at a time.The flooding has
made the local history books, and it is not done done discount soccer cleats done yet.The water is coming in deeper and faster than
expected, North Dakota's governor, Jack Dalrymple, said today.The U.S. Army Army cheap jordan basketball shoes Army Corps of Engineers has released pent-up water from the
Darling Dam, which will push water downstream toward Minot at at jordan basketball shoes at 29,000 cubic feet per second – more than three
the record flow rate before this year and double the the wholesale soccer cleats the projections just four days ago. Those raging waters are

Post a Comment










Commentary Archives

January 2016
December 2015
November 2015
October 2015
September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015

See all Archived Material

MediaVillage.com

Susan Sarandon at the SAGs, Beer Ads and More: Gender News Weekly
Inspired by Jack Myers' new book "The Future of Men: Masculinity in the Twenty-First Century" (coming in March), this is a weekly blog focused on gender equality, gender politics and the shift in gender norms in business and culture. Read on for this week's news roundup.

MediaBizBuzz: The Super Bowl, Comcast, ESPN, Viceland and More
A roundup of the week's key news from MediaVillage member companies and the wider media industry. This week, financial results from Comcast and Google shed more light on viewer and advertising trends, Nielsen fixes ESPN data, digital disrupts jobs at media companies, Yahoo tries to turn around its turnaround, Viceland’s executive landscape becomes clearer and how many digital ads a Super Bowl TV spot can buy.

Why I’m Excited About the Super Bowl for the First Time Ever
I have never been excited about the Super Bowl. I’m not a football fan. I neither enjoy nor understand it. The ads, which I do enjoy, are either released before the game or available immediately afterwards. I rarely care about the half-time performance. I do not like beer, buffalo wings, plain potato chips or really most go-to Super Bowl party refreshments. I do not like Sunday night engagements, as they conflict with “Downton Abbey.” Lest anyone rescind my invitation to their Super Bowl party, I am pleased to say that this year I am extremely excited about the big game. Why? Two words: Fantasy football.

ANA vs. 4As: The Advertiser Agency Battle Rumbles On
The argument between advertisers and media agencies in the USA over transparency rumbles on. Earlier Cog Blogs have commented on advertisers’ concerns over the agencies’ media buying practices, and their hiring (via their trade body the ANA) of two consultancies to look into the whole matter of where the money goes. Now, in what sounds like an attempt to get their retaliation in way before the consultants have even reported, the agencies’ trade body (the 4As) last week issued something called “Transparency Guiding Principles of Conduct.” In line with what seems to be something of a strained atmosphere between the two parties, the 4As did this without any discussion with their clients, whose trade body is as we said in mid-consultation and who might have had something interesting to input into what they consider to be the principles of transparency.

NBC Digital’s Bill Smee on the Evolution of News
News creation and coverage is one area of the media that has seen particular change in the past few years. Affordable easy-to-use production equipment, the shift from film to video to digital formats, advancements in production technology and expansive access to anyone and everyone via the Internet have dramatically shifted the business of news content formation.

Mindshare: Coordinates for the Perfect Playlist
This week on Mindshare’s Culture Vulture Live, Amanda Hechinger explores mobile location data and the opportunities for brands.

Access Confidential Brand Watch: AMA vs. ANA
The pharmaceutical industry is no stranger to controversy of late. Mergers and acquisitions activity, poor press and a divided front on DTC ads may have side effects on 2016 ad budgets.

The MediaVillage Articles Club -- February Selections
When Articles Club met late last month for our first meeting of 2016, we marked an important milestone … our one-year anniversary! While we have only been sharing our recommendations here at MediaVillage for a few months, we have together shared a year’s worth of our favorite articles. If we can just track down those missing spreadsheets from our first few months of meetings, we will have a pretty impressive roster. Our February picks are listed below. For the first time, they include television and radio content.

Data, Consumer Insights and Breaking With the Past
The last several years have delivered significant progress in the data insights sphere. Credit most players in the arena with responding to the changes the digital environment has enabled. Television has responded to improve accountability beyond traditional TV metrics we all grew up with, no small factor in its market resurgence. Agencies and traditional media platforms have instituted the Chief Data Officer position, to signal that “data” has an elevated seat at the table.

Out of Home Poised to Deliver Dynamic Analytics to Advertisers
The data and analytics revolution that ROI-hungry advertisers have been waiting for is upon us.

Five Questions for VSA's Anne-Marie Rosser on Alibaba Defined, China, and the Art of Navigating Cultural Perceptions
VSA's Anne-Marie Rosser was kind enough to take some time to discuss with AdForum's James Thompson the recent collaboration between VSA and Alibaba in developing Alibaba Defined, a comprehensive digital experience created by VSA Partners to help audiences outside of China understand the company.

Cantor Fitzgerald’s Youssef Squali on Ad Technology and 2016 Trends
Jay Sears, Senior Vice President Marketplace Development of Rubicon Project discusses ad technology and 2016 trends with Cantor Fitzgerald’s Internet analyst and Managing Director Youssef Squali.

When Reaching Viewers, Hallmark Gets to the Heart of the Matter
In this era of Peak TV there are more than 1400 series vying for viewers' attention throughout the year. Faced with such mounting competition, how do television programmers cut through the clutter, especially during the frigid winter season when viewing levels tend to be at their highest? Building strategies around holidays helps. "Emotional connections are key drivers in decision-making,” explains Michelle Vicary, Crown Media Family Networks’ Executive Vice President of Programming and Network Program Publicity. She's talking specifically about two of Hallmark Channel's annual programming events: Countdown to Christmas (October 30 – January 1) and Countdown to Valentine’s Day (January 30 – February 14), which deliver on the two big sentiments of the winter season -- connectivity and relationships.

The Year Ahead with Mindshare’s Colin Kinsella: Part 2
In part two of this Mindshare interview series, Colin Kinsella, CEO, North America and Katerina Sudit, Executive Director, North America explore the year ahead for the advertising industry, with a bigger look at influencer marketing and digital content.

Stuart Elliott: Super Bowl Ad Vets vs. Rookies -- Who Will Win?
The big story on Sunday in Super Bowl 50 is likely to be the faceoff between the veterans and the eager rookies. There also are different levels of experience among the football players.

Click Here for Membership Information