Free ContentFor Members Only
Home > JackMyers Media Innovation and Creativity Awards > Myers Media Innovation and Creativity Award Winners-Part 2

Myers Media Innovation and Creativity Award Winners-Part 2

March 22, 2007

Published: March 22, 2007 at 03:14 AM GMT
Last Updated: September 20, 2007 at 03:14 AM GMT

Mindshare and MTV Networks Deliver Winning Entries

During the next several week, the Jack Myers Media Business Report will feature winning entries from the Fourth Annual Myers Media Creativity and Innovation Awards. These winning entries include bronze, silver, gold and platinum award winners. The full slate of winners in each category will be announced in early April along with the Thomas F. Leahy Grand Award for media companies and the Grand Award for agencies. The two winning entries below from MTV Networks and Ameriprise campaign from Mindshare are among the winning entries. The specific level of award will be announced in April.


Company: MindShare
Client: Ameriprise
Category: Agency

Other companies engaged in relationship: Saatchi, Velocity and RF Binder

Description of goals and strategies of program:
The primary goal was to continue to establish Ameriprise Financial as a leader within the financial category. Having launched (as a separate entity from American Express) in September of 2005 the goal was to increase brand awareness, generate leads and acquire new clients.

Leveraging the communications platform of "Dreams Don't Retire" the brand's intent was to differentiate itself from the "sea of sameness" and break through the clutter by leveraging this compelling communications strategy. By developing media partnerships that delivered high impact media opportunities within relevant target environments that leveraged this platform, the Brand was able to achieve and indeed exceed its stated goals.

GM linked the "Dreams Don't Retire" communications platform with a synergistic media strategy Dream>Plan>TrackSM, (Please see below). Through this media strategy the Brand developed fully integrated, 360-degree media executions to infiltrate the target and differentiate from the competition:
Dream: Connect to boomers in environments that reflect their passion points and lifestyle interests (music, home decorating/remodeling, epicurean, travel, sports, and news).
Plan: Reach the target when seeking financial/retirement information through financial/business media vehicles.
Track: Create an on-going conversation with boomers through multimedia programs and franchise media positions.

Description, including what aspects make it worthy of recognition, why it is innovative, how it was developed, presented, approved, and implemented, as well as obstacles confronted during the development, approval and implementation process:
Several tactics based on this overarching concept are described below:
In order to leverage the communications platform through the media strategy the Brand partnered with CNN and Time Inc. to create a true 360 engagement focused content "Life After Work", a custom, integrated, multimedia sponsorship and a true partnership between media and advertiser.


  • Weekly vignettes with an adjacent billboard and :30 spot featured boomers who pursued their dreams in retirement
    • Vignettes aired weekly on CNN properties over a 52-week period

For the first time, an editorial concept from one Time-Warner property was extended to another with the expansion on the program to Time Inc. magazines.

  • Exclusively secured positions adjacent to custom editorial were created in Time, Fortune, and Golf Magazine Living featuring boomers pursuing their retirement dreams.

In celebration of the first baby boomers turning 60 years old in 2006, activity was launched within highly-visible and engaging media around the theme "Happy Birthday Boomers"

  • Custom created "Happy Birthday Boomers" :15 TV spots were placed on New Year's Eve to run in the first break after midnight including appearances in Dick Clark's "New Year's Eve Show" and ran for two weeks thereafter
  • Sponsorship of multi-segment series on Today Show and Good Morning America
  • Sponsored 4-page custom unit in USA Today addressing boomers
  • Study developed on five stages of retirement was transformed into a branded insert for Money and Travel+Leisure
  • Launched the weekly USA Today front page franchise colorbar position

In Q3 2006, fresh creative launched with tons of buzz within highly anticipated positioning during NBC's Sunday Night Football Premiere:

  • Unveiled TV units during the first half of the "Manning Bowl"
  • Excited fans at NBCSports.com
    • Exclusive Countdown Clock sponsorship
    • Fixed homepage presence around the game
    • Web ad presence within Fantasy Sports: Banner and Display ads

Throughout 2006, the Brand tactically used the following media to leverage boomer dreams and passion points:

  • Network Prime, News, Cable Entertainment and Network Radio
    • Placement in top rated and targeted shows including Lost, Grey's Anatomy and Meet the Press
  • Spot Radio (Classic Rock, Adult Contemporary, News/Talk formats)
    • Created a "Dream Concert Series Event" for local Financial Advisors to engage clients and prospective clients with signage and VIP sections featuring some of boomers favorite performers in eleven markets
  • Long-form, multi-page Print units communicated the brand position within lifestyle publications while fractional units leverage editorial relevancy within business and personal finance publications
  • National Newspapers provided ongoing conversation
    • USA Today: main news colorbar with corresponding co-branded Online homepage
    • New York Times: Saturday Business Day section front cover
    • Wall Street Journal: Money & Investing section front cover
  • DRTV, Online and BRCs in personal finance publications compelled consumers to contact Ameriprise Financial to make an appointment with a local Financial Advisor
    • Creative included the Dream BookSM guide, a proprietary retirement planning tool that also drove boomer engagement

Information on how the success of the media program was evaluated and if it was/is likely to be renewed:
While 2006 going-in goals for awareness and acquisition were in place, the Brand revisited the research and findings every week and month to ensure the greatest optimization. To determine the Brand's success, overall key metrics researched were awareness, engagement and conversion. Changes and adjustments were tailored to the habits of boomers on a weekly and monthly basis.

For awareness, AdPhase, a MindShare media research tool was used to project monthly awareness. Phoenix, a third-party research company also tracked the progress of Ameriprise Financial's awareness and market share to draw further conclusions about future media mixes.

Engagement data was compiled through DRTV and Online activity and was tracked via independent third party companies, Intelemedia and Double Click, as well as internal Ameriprise Financial research departments. Data directed the young brand on how to better reach prospective clients.

"We are proud of the 2006 media effort for the results it helped deliver, the innovative thinking it reflected, and the integrated approach it demonstrated." - Giunero A. Floro, VP, Head of Advertising, Brand & Media Advertising, Brand & Media Group, Ameriprise Financial

Research showed Ameriprise Financial's brand awareness goals were well surpassed by the end of 2006.


  • Brand awareness increased by 85% from January-December 2006
  • 2006 year-end awareness exceeded goal by over 35%
  • Ameriprise Financial surpassed its lead generation goals for the year by close to 70%
  • Ameriprise Financial stock went up 25% over the course of the year
  • Based on optimizations:
    • Cost per clicks were down 44% and cost per calls were down 30% based on optimizations overall
      • DRTV began with 21 networks and were optimized to 11 networks by end of year
  • Over 1 million Dream BooksSM were requested since the campaign launch

Additionally, qualitative feedback from consumers and Financial Advisor's has been remarkably positive. The Dream BookSM has mobilized and energized the advisor sales force by giving them a unique selling proposition that drives lead conversion and greater investments. Additionally, continuous optimization of the media plan has helped narrowly focus the development of 2007 plans.

MTV Networks

Company: MTV Networks
Category: Media Company
Other companies engaged in relationship: Hewlett Packard, ZenithOptimedia Worldwide, Goodby Silverstein and Partners

Description of goals and strategies of program:
In May 2006 HP's Personal Systems Group launched their new "Personal Again Campaign".

The objective of this campaign was to transform the consumers' relationship with their PC and to put the "Personal" back into the PC by showing that the computer is not simply a commodity item but a critical part of their everyday lives. It set out to remind users of how personal the content living on their hard drives is…from personal pictures, to music, letters, resumes, calendars and more.

In this process HP wanted to challenge consumers to look again at their PC/ notebook and reevaluate the decisions they had made in its purchase.

HP with their media agency ZenithOptimedia looked to MTV as a key global media partner to help exemplify this campaign and deliver it to a young adult audience in an innovative and compelling way.

Specifically MTV was tasked to expand HP's conversation with the core college influencer audience from which the Meet or Delete franchise was developed by MTV's college network, mtvU.

Description, including what aspects make it worthy of recognition, why it is innovative, how it was developed, presented, approved, and implemented, as well as obstacles confronted during the development, approval and implementation process:
"Meet or Delete" is a unique program with a new twist on getting to know someone, whether it be for a date, a new band member or a potential roommate. Contestants reveal the innermost contents of their personal computers to complete strangers who decide if they want to Meet or Delete them based purely on what they find on their PC.

The show brings the campaign to life by showing that everything you need to know about someone is stored right on their hard drive. It reflects the highly individual and personal relationship young people have with their computers, which have become the emotional hard drive of MTV's global audience.

Further integration with the campaign is achieved by utilizing creative assets and style guides across the shows, from the show logo, type face, website design etc.

In matching the global nature of the new campaign role out from HP Meet or Delete is the first MTV Networks' series to premiere to a global audience whilst leveraging virtually every MTV asset both in the USA with mtvU, MTV2, mtv.com, MTV Wireless, the screen in Time Square, the MTV Store, and internationally across regional networks and local country feed and web sites across Europe, Asia, and Latin America.

To ensure local resonance and relevance with this program we had to develop a global platform to leverage the global assets and talent of the campaign whilst allowing sufficient local flexibility for region and country teams to fully support the program and develop content that really was to hit home in each market.

Content was developed both in the US and locally within a framework set up and approved by the global teams and with an approval process allowing timely visibility of local assets to global client and agency teams for input and approval.

Through this process local markets gave input on product integration, subject matter for the episodes, prizing etc. whilst still building up a global library of content available on line that is immediately recognizable as the global show with the required linkage back to the campaign.

Shows took the form of short form content with a series of 6 minute episodes being developed, all leveraged off the idea, look and feel developed by the global team in the US and working off mtvU's expertise of the college audience and then expanded out for local shows.

In total six episodes were created in the US with one of these being a global pilot show aired across all regions to announce the show in sync with the global launch of HP's new campaign. All US episodes were also versioned for language, format and running time to allow them to run in all other markets. Additionally MTV Europe, Latin America, Australia, India, Korea, and China each created original local episodes.

The show has run across multiple platforms including on air, online and mobile in 10 different languages with 30 different episodes being developed for those regions and markets being further supported by viral campaigns plus on-air and online tune in spots, competitions for HP product and other on the ground activities such as VJ searches and campus parties.

To support the new franchise meetordelete.com was set up as an online global hub. Created in the United States and localized for language and content this site serves as the connective tissue for the Meet or Delete program, while further engaging HP consumers across all channels. The site further integrates campaign assets into its look and feel whilst housing 14 regionalized sites in 10 languages. The site allows enhanced interaction with the all the shows produced plus interactive games, sweepstakes, casting calls and more.

Information on how the success of the media program was evaluated and if it was/is likely to be renewed:
A combination of metrics has allowed ZenithOptimedia and HP to ascertain this programming concept and its execution have been successful for them and has allowed them to extend and deepen the franchise for a further 12 months.

Whilst the majority of metrics are confidential some highlights of metrics we can share are as follows

  • Over 2 million page views onto meetordelete.com
  • Over 700,000 sweepstakes entries to win HP PSG equipment in the US
  • In China the MOD USA pilot show achieved the highest ratings of any show on MTV in the month of July

Specific metrics relating back to the program are confidential (a specific tracking study for Meet or Delete tracking young adults is in place in USA, Mexico, France, Germany, Australia and China).

We are able to report that across all measures relating to the acceptance of the show, HP's participation within the show, the impact of the show on future buying habits and on the appreciation and recognition of HP PC products the scores have been excellent with HP tracking significant gains in many areas.

The franchise has been renewed and extended.

In December 2006 ZenithOptimedia, HP and MTV agreed to a significant increase in focus for Meet or Delete elevating the show to a full 30 minute special airing on MTV in the US and being adapted and picked up across our networks. This event marked the start of season 2 for Meet or Delete and we are excited with what is being planned for the rest of the year with this franchise.

add this social bookmark link

Post a Comment

Commentary Archives

September 2015
August 2015
July 2015
June 2015
May 2015
April 2015
March 2015
February 2015
January 2015
December 2014
November 2014
October 2014

See all Archived Material


"Netflix and Chill": Binge-Watching Reaches a Whole New Level
This week, on Mindshare’s Culture Vulture Live, Aimee Goldfarb talks about the evolution of Netflix in culture. TV addicts, this news is for you: Netflix is playing to the makers movement with the announcement of a connected button called “Netflix and Chill." While you can’t actually purchase the button, Netflix has published instructions for how to create this homegrown device.

Executive Perspectives: Jack Myers
Jack Myers is a Media Ecologist, and as such, he studies media agencies and how these agencies are choosing to spend their media money and on whom they are choosing to spend their money on. The emergence of digital video and the Internet of things (IoT) are massive industry game-changers, as marketing data can come from a multitude of sources. The data is all about the usage, the interpretation and the application of data and this is how media agencies need to position themselves in order to evolve within the industry. Myers has noticed the changes in the bigger media landscape as well. Many networks have moved from a more traditional, impression-based model to a performance-based model, therefore continuing to capitalize on all the emerging trends.

Screenvision Names John Partilla as Chief Executive Officer - Press Release of the Week
Media and Marketing Veteran's Proven Track Record of Innovation Well-Suited to Lead Screenvision into New Era of Growth

Industry Leaders React to comScore’s Acquisition of Rentrak
I have to admit that I was surprised by the news that comScore was acquiring Rentrak. While I expected more consolidation in the media measurement space, I didn't envision that it would be two big players joining forces but rather the continued ingestion of smaller companies by larger companies. This acquisition is not only a brilliant tactical move, it is also strategic: It might finally move analytics and insights in such a way that the industry shifts from the proxy metric of age and gender and into a more standardize-able cross platform measurement.

Newspaper Media Influences Key Constituents
As candidates for the 2016 presidential election declare their candidacy they are also honing in on target constituents, platforms, messaging and media choices. Even at this early stage, targeted reach and differentiation are paramount. What we can all agree on thus far is that the key voters who will “swing the election” are Millennials, Women, Independents, African Americans, Hispanics and Seniors – and, local newspaper media reaches them all in a trustworthy environment.

Give Peace a Chance
In case you missed it, Burger King placed an open letter in today’s New York Times and Chicago Tribune asking McDonald’s to come together on September 21 “Peace One Day” — cast their differences aside with an unprecedented proposition. They are asking to share resources – crew and ingredients in one single pop-up location (based in Atlanta which is neutral ground) to create, serve and sell the McWhopper with all proceeds benefiting Peace One Day” (a not-for-profit).

U.S. Media Planner Survey Takeaway: Disruption Reigns!
Every year our organization, the Digital Place Based Advertising Association, conducts a survey of media planners to take their pulse on the subject of video media and advertising. The 2015 results reinforce what we all sense, i.e., the ground is moving beneath our feet. Disruption reigns.

Not Your Father’s Tune-In -- Part 3
This continues our series probing into best practices in tune-in advertising, practices that have arisen rapidly since analysts began to study set-top box data to know what really works and what doesn’t.

How Muhammed Ali, Joe Frazier and Satellites Changed TV History
The year 1975 is notable for many reasons: The Vietnam War ended with the fall of Saigon; John Mitchell, the Attorney General of the United States, was found guilty of the Watergate cover-up; fugitive Patty Hearst was captured in San Francisco, and NBC aired the first episode of "Saturday Night Live." To many of us laboring in the shallow trenches of cable television, September 30th, 1975 was the night that changed the course of television history.

Exclusive! Meredith to Publish New Lifestyle Title, Beekman 1802 Almanac
Sometimes change happens fast. Sometimes it happens not at all. And sometimes change happens in stages, so that only when you look back do you notice how much ground has been covered. Madison Avenue -- and all of us -- will be reminded of that Oct. 6 when the media giant Meredith is to bring out a new publication, the Beekman 1802 Almanac. It's intended as a premium product, more akin to a book than a magazine, and as a contemporary version of those almanacs once relied upon by farmers. To underscore how contemporary the Beekman 1802 Almanac is meant to be, it's a partnership between Meredith and a same-sex married couple, Josh Kilmer-Purcell and Brent Ridge (pictured above).

Q&A: Hakuhodo’s D.A.Consortium on Automation, Programmatic and TV
Second of a two-part series! Jay Sears, Senior Vice President Marketplace Development of Rubicon Project discusses “Automation, Programmatic and TV” with Kent Isshiki of Hakuhodo’s D.A.Consortium. The two executives appeared at Rubicon Project’s The 2nd Annual Real Time Trading Update from Japan's Buy Side in July 2015.

Can Anything Stop the Rise of the Adblockers?
There’s a very old joke about the adman who when interviewed said, “Don’t tell my mother I work in advertising, she thinks I am a piano player in a brothel.” Indeed, the legendary French adman, Jacques Seguela (the “S” in RSCG, now part of Havas) used the joke as a title for his 1979 book.

Off the Grid a Couple Weeks and the Media/Digital Worlds Go Wild!
So I got back to the connected world and caught up on the news on the flights toward America from Lisbon … business culture shock. The media and digital worlds shifted into overdrive while I was off the grid in a kayak mostly atop the Duoro River in Northern Portugal. Here are just a few of the harbingers and changers:

Is Online Media “A Market for Lemons”?
“[In a ‘market for lemons’] there is an incentive for sellers to market poor quality merchandise, since the returns for good quality accrue mainly to the entire group whose statistic is affected rather than to the individual seller. As a result there tends to be a reduction in the average quality of goods” -- George Akerlof, from “The Market for ‘Lemons’: Quality, Uncertainty and The Market Mechanism”

A Sudden Surge in Smart TV-Making Devices
Random notes from this busy fall season: With Apple TV 2.0's availability just a few weeks away, the rest of the smart TV-making device field appears not to be standing still, whether or not there's fear of losing market share. Google's Chromecast 2.0 gets unveiled this week, while the second edition of Amazon Fire TV comes out within two weeks and Nvidia's Shield displays for the first time since its May rollout at Pepcom's Digital Experience showcase here in New York Wednesday night. There is a sense that everyone wants to be ready if Apple CEO Tim Cook's declaration that "the future of TV is apps" – as in informational, transactional or interactive services -- pans out. Travel site Orbitz is now an Amazon Fire attraction, and similar apps for TV are reportedly on the fast track at Chromecast, Roku, Shield and Intel's Compute Stick.

Click Here for Membership Information